Johnson will leave Marquette as a three-time All-American in this event. She earned a spot on the second team after placing 12th with a mark of 151-10.
Williams finished 15th (150-4) while Shove took 22nd (137-1). Northern Michigan led all schools with three discus throw participants.
Previously, Johnson earned first team All-American honors at the 2016 and 2015 NCAA Outdoor Track & Field Championships, claiming sixth (155-10) and eighth (159-2) respectively. She and Williams each qualified for three outdoor championship meets while Wildcats.